INTRODUCTION
Today’s conversation is with Nadine Nye, a Speech Language Pathologist, She’s licensed to treat a variety of problems arising from damage to the brain. Nadine finished her Clinical Fellowship at Princeton in 1988. Since then she’s helped innumerable individuals, and she’ll share with us her unique perspectives on the challenges that arise after a stroke.
DISCLAIMER
Neither Joel, Drew nor Tom are doctors or any other kind of medical provider. We do not and cannot provide any medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. The content provided in the program is for informational purposes only, and is not intended to substitute professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
Please do not disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking help because of something you may have heard on this program or any materials referenced in this program. We direct you to seek medical advice from qualified healthcare professionals such as physicians or medical specialists.
Transcript:
Drew Summins:
I am Drew Simmons
Joel Fine:
And, I’m Joel Fine.
Drew Summins:
Welcome to Stoke Voices.
Joel Fine:
We created this show because so many people just wanted to know that they’re not alone.
Drew Summins:
It’s important to understand that no two strokes are the same. While strokes are undeniably challenging, there’s always a chance to find something good that comes from the experience. Stroke voices dives into the topics that matter most.
Joel Fine:
…diets, therapies, innovations…
Drew Summins:
…and conversations that can inspire real change in the lives of stroke patients and their families. We’re thrilled to have you with us on this journey as we navigate the path forward together.
Joel Fine:
Thank you for joining us and enjoy the show!
Drew Summins:
Today’s conversation is with Nadine Nye, a speech language pathologist. She is licensed to treat a variety of problems arising from damage to the brain. Nadine finished her clinical fellowship at Princeton in 1988. Since then, she’s helped innumerable individuals, and she’ll share with us her unique perspectives on the challenges that arise after a stroke.
Your profession is so unique. What got you into it? Is this a family thing—like you had a mother or an aunt who did this? 01:21
Nadine Nye:
In high school, I had an interest in sign language. So, I went to Harrisburg Area Community College and took sign language classes. Thought it was really cool and fun. I had planned to be a deaf education teacher. I went to Penn State and Asa Berlin was my professor. Once I got up there, he explained that communication disorders was Penn State’s broader program and that the deaf education world was changing. So, he encouraged me to take some speech pathology classes and I went that direction and loved it—and the rest is history.
Joel Fine:
Wow. And you went to some really good schools, too. 02:20
Nadine Nye:
I did. So, my background is Penn State undergrad in communication disorders and then Rutgers Graduate School for speech pathology. Then I did my externship at Penn in Philadelphia. Then I did a clinical fellowship year, which is required for all speech pathologists, at the Princeton Medical Center. Then I stayed on and worked for Princeton, both at the medical center and their outpatient clinic. Then the core of my younger age career was at Magee Rehab in Philadelphia. I also spent some time, as I was raising my kids—I did more per diem work, worked for Moss Rehab, worked for Genesis. Then when I was helping my parents out, I worked at Penn State, Hershey Rehab. Then for quite a few years now, since being full-time in Utah, I’ve worked for Intermountain Health.
Joel Fine:
Nadine, do you interact a lot with others—with like, Stephanie and Christy? 03:22
Nadine Nye:
Absolutely, yes. Speech pathologists are part of a team, particularly in the neuro world.
Drew Summins:
You talked about the team. The team is you and other therapists, but it’s focused around the patient. Is that correct? 03:36
Nadine Nye:
Correct. Most traditionally, it’s physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy. That’s the standard. In some different programs where I’ve worked, things get a little bit more elaborative and you can have recreational therapists, music therapists, case managers/social workers—neuropsychologists.
Drew Summins:
So, who decides which of those therapists are appropriate for a given patient? 04:11
Nadine Nye:
Typically the overseeing medical doctor in the rehab world is a physiatrist—physical medicine and rehabilitation, that doctor will put in the orders. It depends what the sequence was. If someone had a stroke that required acute care in a hospital and then they went to inpatient rehab, all those three disciplines—primary disciplines are going to evaluate a person. Then if they come into the home care and then the outpatient world, typically, all three disciplines—if they were seen acutely, that follows along. Or a team member, let’s say someone might just have physical therapy to start, but then that physical therapist says, Hey, I think I’m seeing some cognitive, or communication, or speech issues. I’m going to put in a request that the doctor order an evaluation for speech.
Drew Summins:
When you work as a team, you’ve got the doctor, you’ve got the therapist—do you call it a patient? 05:21
Nadine Nye:
We still do. I think sometimes—now particularly here at Park City Hospital, our neuro clinic is truly a community-based entity. So, I personally tend to prefer client, but in the broad sense of things everybody still uses patient.
Drew Summins:
You’ve got all the therapists, you’ve got the doctor providing input—what about input from the client. Is that part of it? 05:50
Nadine Nye:
Absolutely. I mean, I think I pride myself in trying to be a very functional therapist and needing to know what someone’s communication needs are for who they are.
Joel Fine:
Have you ever had a client that you just couldn’t work with and couldn’t help? I mean, it’s too complex or that they were just too far gone, so to speak. 06:13
Nadine Nye:
I would say no, that even someone with profound aphasia—and we can back up a little bit and define some of the terms. But, someone that has a severe communication impairment, we still give it our best shot. There’s augmentative communication that we need to try from a simple handmade board to more sophisticated computers.
Joel Fine:
If you want to discuss what you do just go through your job and terms and whatever…
Drew Summins:
…and particularly, through the lens of stroke survivors because the podcast is mainly focused on people who have had strokes. 07:07
Nadine Nye:
Speech language pathologists—so SLPs treat a wide variety of communication disorders. But, in terms of stroke patients, it is primarily aphasia, dysarthria, apraxia, cognitive communication disorders, and swallowing or dysphagia. To back up, aphasia is a broad term for a language-based disorder. It can be receptive. It can be expressive. It can involve reading and writing. Typically all four of those modalities of communication are assessed in an aphasia assessment.
Then with dysarthria, that’s when you actually have weakness in the oral motor structure. Sounds can be distorted—not clear. With apraxia it is a motor speech disorder where there’s a disconnect between the brain and the oral motor functioning. Sometimes we actually call it articulatory groping, where someone’s trying to make a sound and just can’t get to the right spot. So, it ends up coming out somewhat disfluently.
With the aphasia, it tends to be more left hemisphere areas of stroke. Then with right side hemisphere or some frontal strokes, it tends to be more cognitive communication deficits, meaning attention, memory, problem solving, executive functions, the ability to plan and execute intentions. Swallowing can really be involved with either side, and it tends to be a weakness and a slowed response time of swallowing. So those are all the different areas that we tend to work with with stroke survivors.
Drew Summins:
So, you have to come up with a strategy to work with the client? 09:21
Nadine Nye:
Step one is always evaluation. There are many standardized assessments. One of the true classics is the Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination, the BDAE and the Boston Naming Test. Those are very widely used by most speech pathologists. Then on the right side strokes, then things tend to be a little bit more cognitive. The Cognitive Linguistic Quick Test is one that I use a lot. The Repeatable Battery for the Assessment of Neuropsychological Status. RBANS is another one that I use a lot.
Joel Fine:
Can you talk in generalities? I mean, are Drew and I very bad cases, or are we okay? I mean, relatively. 10:08
Nadine Nye:
I think you’re both doing great. I read an interesting article. Let me see if I can just find this. In terms of classifying someone mild, moderate or severe. There is some discrepancy. I mean, when you do a standardized test and you calculate the outcome numbers, most of those standardized tests give you a rating. But, I love this sentence. It depends on the degree to which aphasia impairs someone’s ability to communicate at the level demanded by their own personal, social, vocational, educational, and recreational needs.
Drew Summins:
That makes sense. So it’s probably more critical for somebody still engaged professionally—earning a living. 11:02
Nadine Nye:
Correct.
Drew Summins:
Say one of the people listening to this just had a stroke a month ago. Three weeks ago. When do they start, typically, with speech language pathologists? 11:12
Nadine Nye:
The sooner the better. In terms of actual statistical prognostic indicators, the ones that have withstood the length of time is: the size of the lesion; the size of the damage in the brain; where exactly in the brain; the health of the person; the severity; and then the Time Post Onset. So, the sooner you start, the better your prognosis.
Drew Summins:
Okay. And, for somebody who lives in a city, a big city, that’s fairly straightforward. But, if you’re in a rural setting, it’s harder to find—what’s a good resource for people who don’t live in cities to try to find a therapist? 11:55
Nadine Nye:
Well, that’s actually a great, great question. It’s interesting, Park City is even considered rural. It’s quasi-rural, but again, we’re lucky to have such a great program and team here. But, it really only started here, maybe, six years ago. Seven years ago if someone had a stroke they would have had to go down to Salt Lake.
I think telehealth is growing in leaps and bounds. I much prefer in-person, but if someone cannot get to an office, a clinic, a hospital, once evaluation is completed in-person, then I think telehealth can be a really decent option.
Drew Summins:
So, you can do your therapy via telehealth? 13:02
Nadine Nye:
Yes. So, right now it is state-dependent. We cannot—because of our unique location, we have a fair number of Wyoming patients, but I cannot have a telehealth session with someone in Nevada or Wyoming. They actually have to go somewhere over the Utah state line, and then I can hold a telehealth.
Drew Summins:
That’s a regulatory limitation.
Nadine Nye:
Yes, it all has to do with insurance, basically.
Drew Summins:
Okay. Makes sense.
Nadine Nye:
But let’s go on to the assessment and the diagnosis. So again, a doctor makes the referral. A speech pathologist meets with the person and hopefully a family member, or a support member, or a loved one, a friend. We do both formal and informal assessment, meaning those standardized tests. But, I also do just a conversational assessment meaning, Tell me about you. What are your passions? What is or was your vocation? What are your own personal goals? What is most bothering you about your speech or language, or reading or writing, or your cognition since your stroke?
Then we go through a method of goal development. In the rehab world, most treatments are planned in the outpatient world—are planned for ninety days or three months. Then we do a reassessment and we can continue on. But, a lot of folks, that’s what they need.
Then we launch them. But, not to say that we can’t work with some people for years. Neuro-rehab is based on neuroplasticity, meaning that the brain recovers. I love to use again—because of where we live, but oftentimes a stroke is like an avalanche happened and you can’t take that road. You can’t take that primary road home anymore because the road’s blocked, but you’re going to take a detour and wind your way around and still get home. And, the more you take that detour, the easier it becomes. The faster it becomes, the more familiar it becomes. So, other areas of the brain are able to step up and take over for the area of the brain that was damaged.
Drew Summins:
That’s a great analogy. I never heard that. I like that.
Nadine Nye:
Then in terms of how often the person needs to be seen anywhere from one to three times a week, over that three month period. Goals evolve over time. Maybe you achieve one goal and you want to modify it on recovery. A lot of people ask for a prognosis date, and in a very broad sense, most people make their best recovery in a year. But certainly—and I know Doctor Taubin uses a two-year point. That’s not to say that you cannot continue to keep working on things forever.
Drew Summins:
Sure. I know anecdotally, I’ve found online quite a few stories of people who, many years after a stroke, find that they’re still improving.
Nadine Nye:
Absolutely.
Drew Summins:
So five, six, seven years. I mean, way out. So yeah. 16:43
Nadine Nye:
I totally agree. I’m working with one gentleman now that had intensive speech therapy right after his stroke. He was very aphasic and very apraxic, and made good progress to become functional in a simple social situation. I think he’s five years’ out, six years’ out, and all of a sudden he’s feeling gung ho and wants to try another round of therapy, and he’s doing great.
Drew Summins:
I like that because it suggests to people who are new to this stroke lifestyle that—don’t give up. Right.
Nadine Nye:
Absolutely.
Drew Summins:
Yeah. That’s good. Do you engage in the therapy sessions with the family members? 17:26
Nadine Nye:
Always as best as I can. Yeah, I always invite the family members or friends to be a part of it so they know what to support. Sometimes I get better insight, maybe, into a situation by a loved one sharing their own observations. And, it depends too. Like with swallowing, if there’s safety concerns with someone potentially aspirating, meaning that liquid or food is going down the trachea, not the way it’s supposed to go—oftentimes that loved one may need to really be overseeing safe swallowing strategies that a speech therapist has recommended.
I’d love the chance to talk about family and caregiver support, too. Back at Magee in Philly, I had founded what was called the Partners Program, and this was more on the brain injury unit—we actually had three units. We had a spinal cord injury unit, a stroke unit, and a brain injury unit. I was the supervisor of speech on the brain injury unit, but this doesn’t mean that this is not also completely applicable to the stroke world.
I would pair someone further out in their recovery to a newer person that had just had a brain injury. So, it was amazing. Talking about giving hope, and just people sharing their experience, their journey. That veteran that was longer out in their recovery became very inspirational to someone that more newly had had a stroke.
Drew Summins:
Right. You can see that there’s a potential end point.
Nadine Nye:
Yes.
Drew Summins:
Yeah. That’s so awesome.
Nadine Nye:
Here at Park City Hospital, I do two support groups. I do a neuro rehab support group, and then I do a Parkinson’s support group. It’s just invaluable. I either find a topic and facilitate a conversation around it, or I bring in outside speakers, but the friendships, the resources that are shared—I just, it’s one of my favorite parts of what I do.
Then in terms of loved ones, caregivers, care partners, depending on what semantics you like, depending on the person’s communication impairment, there can be what’s called communicative burden on the partner. If someone is severely aphasic, but maybe it’s a person that’s been married for forty or fifty years to a person and they can almost know what a facial expression is or what that person is trying to express. That’s where I think we’re seeing spinoffs of my support groups where just the caregivers are getting together, or they find their own caregivers support group to talk about what it’s like on that side.
Drew Summins:
Caregivers support group. That’s awesome because I know the burden is huge on the family. I’ve talked to Trin about our situation, especially right after the stroke—is massive. It took all of her time. My son’s also incredible. The cost of the family was huge. Yeah, we’re still tight. Luckily we were tight going in. We’re even tighter coming out of the hard part. So that’s good that there’s a support group just for the family. The caregiver. Yeah. 20:46
Nadine Nye:
Because, I don’t mean it to sound cliche, but if that person isn’t taking care of themselves, they can’t necessarily give their best to their loved one.
Drew Summins:
Right.
Nadine Nye:
And some people have to be convinced to go and do a little self-care, or just relax and have some time to themselves, and not feel guilty about it, that they need to reboot so they can give the best support they can.
Drew Summins:
Sure. Right.
Nadine Nye:
Then I think you guys had a question about some technology and tools. Obviously the tech world is rapidly changing. It’s not my forte. [laughter] But, we’re lucky here we have the Utah Assistive Technology Center. They’re based out of Salt Lake, but I can make a referral regarding a client and they will send a specialist up, bringing different augmentative communication tools or apps.
In the past year, I’ve had the guys from there come up twice and help someone that was severely aphasic put a program on an iPad to better be able to communicate her basic needs to her family. That was exciting, and then we have a gentleman that is losing his speech through a very rare diagnosis, and he’s using a text-to-speech app on his phone.
Drew Summins:
Okay.
Nadine Nye:
We spend our time then—once that specialist tells me what app or what program might best fit this client, then it’s my job as the speech therapist to keep practicing it and make it more and more functional, user-friendly, and successful.
Joel Fine:
Are there some patients that you just can’t help at all because they’re so bad or they don’t want help. 23:13
Nadine Nye:
There are those that don’t necessarily want to do the therapy and I can offer, or I should speak in a general sense, a speech pathologist can offer services, but sometimes a person just doesn’t want it. Or sometimes, the personalities maybe don’t jive, and you can recommend that they try a different therapist.
Joel Fine:
You know what? What I’m hearing is one, don’t give up. You may make small improvements and you may get better altogether. I mean, but the key is to have patience and time is on your side. Is that correct? 23:45
Nadine Nye:
Yes. Yeah. So, I’ve done some private practice over the years. I had a gentleman that was running his own construction company and had a pretty severe right hemisphere stroke, but I worked with him privately for a good year and a half, maybe close to two years, and even going into his home office, running the construction company and trying to make modifications, and make sure that everything was as streamlined and organized for him, that he could then continue to run his business.
I love the community side of things—back when I worked at Magee, we actually had what was called a community reentry program, and I ran that for a while. After someone finished, like a traditional outpatient program, but needed to go back to work or to school, I and some other staff members, would work as the liaisons if we needed to meet with someone’s boss, if we needed to meet with someone’s professor and advocate for accommodations, and just providing that education sometimes, again, oftentimes a stroke or a brain injury, it’s an absolutely invisible condition. So the public, or bosses, or professors place demands on someone thinking that there’s absolutely nothing challenging this person, and that’s not the case.
Joel Fine:
Do you ever find clients or patients that just say, Screw it, I’m tired of this. And really it’s terrible… 25:46
Nadine Nye:
No, Joe, I don’t do that. That is not professionalism. I work with someone as long as they want to work, and as long as they’re still making progress.
Joel Fine:
Okay. Thank you. Yeah. Like I said, I wasn’t trying to put you on the spot, but I mean, some people just don’t give a flying patoot. I mean, that concerns me. 26:08
Nadine Nye:
Everybody’s an individual. But, you know, for the most part, people are motivated to continue to improve. I know one of your other questions was about practice outside of structured therapy?
Drew Summins:
Home stuff to do. Yeah. 26:40
Nadine Nye:
There’s actually a program called Constant Therapy where a speech pathologist can oversee via email and the Constant Therapy Program that someone’s working on their iPad or their computer at home. That’s a pretty cool system, and that can give people a lot of practice.
From a cognitive standpoint, there are apps called Elevate and Luminosity that give you building blocks to just keep working on memory and attention and problem-solving and things like that. So, huge fan of the New York Times games, like Letter Boxed…
Drew Summins:
I do those every day, yeah.
Nadine Nye:
…for word retrieval and the crossword and connections. So, I encourage people to do what they already did or to build upon that if, Oh, well, I used to do a crossword puzzle a day. Keep doing it. That is great word stimulation, word retrieval.
But I do think some things that I’ve watched over my thirty-five-plus-year career are folks with a good sense of humor, and those that actually carry out what’s advised to do at home in the community have the best success. But humor is huge. I think that it comes with positivity. Folks that have—I always say it this way: acceptance is empowering. You suffered a tragedy, but accepting what skills you have and capitalizing on those becomes very empowering and allows people to get back to things that they’re passionate about.
Joel Fine:
Can you comment on the issue of changes in personality? Do you see that quite a bit? 28:38
Nadine Nye:
I’m going to say from a stroke standpoint personality does not typically change. When you get into cognitive impairment from brain injury, or if you get into the true dementias, then you see more personality change.
One of your items was about encouragement and hope. I could go on for hours about success stories, but there was one woman, this was back in Hershey—severe stroke and severe, both aphasia and apraxia. At the very beginning she could not speak. Then we start at the very basics, just getting the brain and body to coordinate again—that you have control over your breath. It would be something as simple as blowing bubbles like a cause and effect. You’re controlling your breath, which you need to do for voice and speech, but you’re blowing, just blowing bubbles.
Well, she had the most delightful personality, just so fun and so rapidly progressed from not being able to speak or control motor movements, to blowing bubbles, to making sounds, to making words and then becoming conversational again. That was quite a few years ago. I still like to talk to her once or twice a year on the phone just to see how she’s doing. She is traveling again and just doing great.
Drew Summins:
At this point, when you talk to her, other than the fact that you know that she had a stroke, is she so far beyond problems, speech problems that the average person would not recognize that she had a stroke? 30:39
Nadine Nye:
I think the average person would still know that she has to pause to find her words. And then sometimes the sound is not the accurate production that she’s hoping for, but she certainly makes her point.
Drew Summins:
Gotcha.
Nadine Nye:
…and, can ask questions, and provide humor, and opinion, and live life.
Drew Summins:
Live life—yeah.
Nadine Nye:
Yes, absolutely.
Joel Fine:
Thank you very much.
Drew Summins:
And thank you for your time.
Nadine Nye:
Have a good rest of the day.
Drew Summins:
You too.
Nadine Nye:
All right. Well, I’m just thrilled that this is ongoing. And again, keep me in the loop. If I can do anything else let me know. It’s all good.
Drew Summins:
This concludes our episode. Thanks for listening. Neither Joel, Drew, nor Tom are doctors or any other kind of medical provider. We do not and cannot provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The content provided in the program is for informational purposes only and is not intended to substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Please do not disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking help because of something you may have heard on this program, or any materials referenced in this program. We direct you to seek medical advice from qualified health care professionals, such as physicians or medical specialists.